Phytoremediation Question

Dear Mr Kwok,


It was a pleasure to read your post on the topic "Before you write off a plant as a weed, read this...".

I enjoyed reading the article and found the information on phytoremediation both fascinating and very comprehensive.

I will like ask if there are any regulatory or monetary policies in Singapore to be considered in regards to phytoremediation applications.

I don't seem to be able to find this information and will really appreciate your sage advice.

Thank you.

Warm Regards,

J

Dear J,



Glad to know that you enjoy reading my blog article.


Incidentally, you did not mention your purpose of using phytoremediation. In it for treatment of industrial waste? Agricultural waste? Domestic waste? Rainwater harvesting? Or simply storm water filtration? Are you using it to clean water or soil or perhaps even air?


As far as I know, there are no regulations in Singapore governing the use of phytoremediation per se. However, there are likely to be regulations controlling the end result of your phytoremediation endeavour which is tied to your purpose of application. For example, if you intend to use phytoremediation to treat industrial waste before discharge into the sewers, you will have to adhere to National Environment Agency (NEA) effluent discharge limits which may or may not make phytoremediation feasible.


Public Utilities Board (PUB) does have some guidelines (Active, beautiful, clean waters design guidelines) pertaining to the design and use of water design features (e.g. bio swales, rain gardens, wetlands) to clean up storm water.


What do you mean by monetary policy? If you are referring to monetary incentives, no, I have not heard anything. The closest is PUB is quite ready to invest in pilot-scale floating wetlands in its reservoirs (Jurong Lake, Pandan Reservoir, Sengkang Floating Wetland) and a full-scale constructed wetland (Lorong Halus Wetland at Serangoon Reservoir) to try out phytoremediation.


Phytoremediation is an emerging technique in environmental pollution control. But it lacks documentation of successful applications in this part of the world. And no matter where in the world it is used, phytoremediation takes relatively long for treatment to complete and precious land is needed grow and maintain the plants that form the heart of a phytoremediation system. Money will certainly trickle into R&D in phytoremediation though I am not sure that money will be gushing into full-scale application of phytoremediation anytime soon, at least not in this part of the world.


CK

How to get rid of your seemingly unstoppable pond algae

Excessive growth of algae (aka algal bloom or eutrophication) is not a new problem in Singapore. You can sometimes see a canal or even a reservoir taking on an unnatural greenish or bluish tinge. For the aquarium hobbyist, it is just as tough a nut to crack as the algae is removed physically, chemically or biologically, only to return with fresh vigour after a while, seeminlgly impossible to kill.

Figure: "Orange" algae in stream in Chinese Garden (Apr 2011)

 Figure: Pond badly overgrown with "green" algae at Sungei Buloh Wetland Reserve (SBWR) (Mar 2011)


Figure: Another shot of the same pond in SBWR (Mar 2011)


With a sprinkling of scientific principles, here are my sentiments on curbing this tough guy.

First: scoping out your opponent
Find out who this tough guy really is. Algae comes in all sorts of flavours, from red, green, blue-green, brown to diatoms and dinoflagellates. To really nail it down to species level, you will need molecular techniques in well equipped labs. Since most of us do not have access to such high powered stuff, we will have to settle on visual examination under microscope. (I agree that most of us do not have a microscope stashed away at home either but at least most schools should have a few to play with.)

 Figure: Microcystis spp under 10x magnification

Figure: Anabaena sp under 10x magnification


Once you have an idea of your guy, check out his characteristics. How does he grow? What are his most important nutrients? Which nutrient is the limiting one? In the case of the above 2 algae, they normally bloom in an excess of phosphorus usually in the form of phosphate.

Second: scoping out your water
Hey, this is water quality blog so yes, you have to check out your water quality. The standard parameters include: dissolved oxygen (DO), electrical conductivity (EC), turbidity, pH, alkalinity, hardness, nitrate, ammonia, phosphate, biochemical oxygen demand (BOD), chemical oxygen demand (COD). Feel free to add more if you have the resources but the above should be a good starting point. Throw in chlorophyll a (a chemical found in algae) if you think you are up to it.

Go through your water quality data. Is there anything wrong besides the algae you observe? Anything amiss could point to some systemic problem that might have triggered the algal bloom. Following the above examples of Microcystis and Anabaena, the phosphate level is likely to be elevated.

Comparative studiesUnfortunately, it is hard to define what is meant by elevated in a natural environment impacted by numerous uncontrollable factors. One way is to make comparisons. Ideally, you should compare the same variable against time i.e. what was the phosphate level 1 year, 5 years, 10 years ago. Unfortunately, almost no one in Singapore (short of PUB in their reservoirs) does regular long term water quality monitoring (WQM) of their water bodies.

The alternative is to compare against a nearby "clean" water body. Since it is algae free, does it have a lower phosphate level?


Third: scope out your environment
Assuming you have discovered elevated phosphate level in your algae infested pond, ask: where does it come from? What are the sources of water flowing into your pond? Does surface run-off carry fertilisers from your next door vegetable farm neighbour into your pond?

You may have to check historical records too as your pond  may be sitting on an old farming area. If your pond sediment is choked full of phosphate from chicken waste from the previous chicken farm, you will have to get rid of the sediment.

I am all for long term solutions so learning the source of problem and tackling it at the source has always been my principle.


Fourth: ACT
As mentioned earlier, you may have the option of physical, chemical and biological methods.

Physical
Drain your pond and dredge out your sediment if it is the source of phosphate. You may also mechanically remove your algae via nets and filters

Chemical
Add alum or other chemicals (there are quite a few exotic ones in the market now) to bind the phosphate in your water into solid form and remove the solids.

Biological
By the nature of their operations (e.g. nature parks), some organisations are reluctant to use physical and chemical methods. Biological methods like phytoremediation appears appealing because of their naturalness. Yet, they may not pack the punch necessary to remove the nutrient (e.g. phosphate) sufficiently.
Other actions
Naturally, if the source of nutrient appears to come from your surroundings, you probably to get your neighbours into the picture to discuss ways to resolve your problem.

Some thoughts on "lower half of body found in Bedok Reservoir"

Here is a follow-up to the article "Lower half of body found in Bedok Reservoir" in Straits Times on 21 Jun 2011 to tie up some loose ends.

No disrespect is meant by any of the comments here to the deceased and members of his family.

Being found decomposing in a reservoir, the body is bound to gather questions from the public about its effects on the reservoir's water quality and ultimately, the quality of the tap water. Since most of us live in a highly urbanised society, we tend to forget that we are still very much part of the web of life. Life and death go on continuously in the web of life, regardless of our humanly desires, emotions or concepts e.g. justice.

Chemically speaking, we are simply bundles of water, fats, proteins and minerals, similar to many animals. A reservoir, whether artificial or natural, provides for a diversity of life - an ecology unto itself. When a living thing dies in it or a human body somehow ends up in it, it will be decomposed by the same microbes and converted into the same end products e.g. carbon dioxide. (Strictly speaking though, the exact environmental conditions e.g. presence of air, determine the type of end products produced.) No, my friends, we are not so different from other living beings.


Of course, some  may point out the possibility of the presence of pathogens (water borne diseases) in the waters of Bedok Reservoir due to the body. In most cases where such diseases became epidemic (floods, earthquakes), the water body has been contaminated by an overwhelming number of dead bodies or excessive dose of human waste. A single body in a normal reservoir will not likely give rise to a concentration of pathogens of concern.

Lastly, our reservoir water goes through water treatment (Bedok Waterworks) before ending up in your tap. Singapore's water treatment process is adequate to remove harmful substances, including pathogens, under normal conditions.

So drink well...